You thought we were all going to be talking about the actual football when once the Premier League got back underway, didn't you? You were wrong.

Ad

Technology reigned supreme on the opening night of top flight action as goal-line technology failed to return from holiday in time to rule Sheffield United's goal as a goal – despite Aston Villa keeper Orjan Nyland carrying the ball over the line, through the Holte End and halfway across the Midlands.

But arguably the biggest source of discussion has revolved around the artificial crowd noise sourced in by Sky Sports during their coverage.

Fans watching both Sheffield United v Aston Villa and Manchester City v Arsenal had the option to flick between two Sky Sports channels (Main Event and Premier League) with fake crowd noises and chants on one side, and natural in-stadium audio on the other.

So, we have a question. Fake crowd noise – yay or nay?

Sky Sports have partnered with EA Sports – creators of the FIFA game franchise – to use their wealth of crowd noises to bring an atmosphere to otherwise largely silent games.

Their innovative system is used to raise the noise levels during attacking moments, react to incidents including bad tackles, shots that fly just wide, and of course the actual goals.

As the season continues, it will be interesting to see how other broadcasters approach artificial sounds and whether public opinion sways in one direction or the other.

Have your say. Vote above to share your opinion on fake crowd noise and whether you'll keep going with it, or switch to the more natural shouts and hollers of players on the field.

Ad

Check out our guide for a full round up of Premier League fixtures on TV in the coming weeks.

Authors

Michael PottsSport Editor, RadioTimes.com

Comments, questions and tips

Rate this recipe

What is your star rating out of 5?

Choose the type of message you'd like to post

Choose the type of message you'd like to post

Overall rating

Ad
Ad
Ad
Create an image depicting a festive scene with elements from the top Christmas songs, such as a snowy New York for 'Fairytale of New York', a cozy home setting for 'Last Christmas', and a glamorous Christmas party for 'All I Want for Christmas Is You'. Include musical notes and festive decorations to represent the spirit of these iconic Christmas songs.

RT offer

Immediate’s iconic brands reach 21m people every month – that’s more than a third of the UK’s adults – through its world-class magazines, innovative digital products and exciting live events

hello
An image depicting a festive scene with iconic Christmas elements such as a beautifully decorated Christmas tree with twinkling lights, snow gently falling, and perhaps a cozy fireplace in the background. The image should capture the essence of popular Christmas songs, with musical notes and lyrics subtly included in the design, representing a playlist of classic Christmas tunes.

summer

Immediate’s iconic brands reach 21m people every month – that’s more than a third of the UK’s adults – through its world-class magazines, innovative digital products and exciting live eventsImmediate’s iconic brands reach 21m people every month – that’s more than a third of the UK’s adults – through its world-class magazines, innovative digital products and exciting live eventsImmediate’s iconic brands reach 21m people every month – that’s more than a third of the UK’s adults – through its world-class magazines, innovative digital products and exciting live events

More