Last year's Love Island winner Nathan Massey spots his water bottle in the villa

Last night, 2016 winner Nathan Massey spotted that his personalised water bottle from the previous year had been recycled for newcomer Nathan.

https://twitter.com/NathanMassey_/status/882332933520060416

ITV2 then refused to deny the accusation, choosing instead to plead the fifth amendment of the US constitution, or the right to remain silent.

https://twitter.com/itv2/status/882349943847096320

It's no wonder Massey is upset: had he managed to hold on to his he may have made a tidy profit. The personalised bottles have become wrapped up in the hysteria surrounding the show, leading many viewers to seek out replicas of their own. The Love Island app is selling them for £18.40.

https://twitter.com/DaniEmilyx/status/881571214258561024
https://twitter.com/_emilywatton/status/881978021393170433

There's a glitch in the @LoveIsland app ? I can't get to the shop section! I need a water bottle!!

— Georgina Leigh (@georgina_leighc) June 24, 2017

But before we put the show's producers to the sword, we must consider one alternative sequence of events: it's entirely possible that new Nathan's bottle just happens to look the exact same as Massey's old bottle because they share the same name. Just a hunch.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=videoseries?list=PLbs-Pk9dtKb8YP3Qd5UDiUQqkuzd776iF&showinfo=0?ecver=1