A critic is feeling the full-force of the internet's ire after claiming women "are incapable" of understanding GoodFellas.

Ad

Kyle Smith, a film reviewer for The New York Post, argued in his article that GoodFellas is a story of "ball-busting etiquette" and that women simply feel "left out" of of the 1990 Martin Scorsese classic.

Men, he argues, don't talk to each other about the women in their lives because "that's too real", instead preferring to "bust each other's balls" and "keep the laughs coming".

He claims this is the essence of GoodFellas; that men ultimately aspire to be the film's lazy, funny yet deadly central cast. Women, on the other hand, see Robert de Niro's gang as "lowlifes".

Twitter has responded with predicable outrage at the writer's generalisations:

https://twitter.com/rgay/status/608856090994995200

Re: the ny post 'tink piece' about women not understanding Goodfellas. True. As a womyn, Joe Pescis voice is too high-pitched for me 2 hear

— The Frenemy Online (@The_Frenemy) June 11, 2015

The article goes on to jokingly re-imagine the mafia masterpiece as told by a woman, which partly focusses on the social services being "sadly lacking" at the time. Twitter has also been quick to point out just who the film's executive producer was:

ERM Barbara De Fina exec produced this movie?? WTF >> "Women are not capable of understanding GOODFELLAS" http://t.co/G0zTKkkFZu #scriptchat

— Lucy Hay (@Bang2write) June 11, 2015

Ad

In the past, Kyle Smith has been described as "America's most cantankerous critic" by Atlantic Magazine.

Comments, questions and tips

Rate this recipe

What is your star rating out of 5?

Choose the type of message you'd like to post

Choose the type of message you'd like to post

Overall rating

Ad
Ad
Ad
Create an image depicting a festive scene with elements from the top Christmas songs, such as a snowy New York for 'Fairytale of New York', a cozy home setting for 'Last Christmas', and a glamorous Christmas party for 'All I Want for Christmas Is You'. Include musical notes and festive decorations to represent the spirit of these iconic Christmas songs.

RT offer

Immediate’s iconic brands reach 21m people every month – that’s more than a third of the UK’s adults – through its world-class magazines, innovative digital products and exciting live events

hello
An image depicting a festive scene with iconic Christmas elements such as a beautifully decorated Christmas tree with twinkling lights, snow gently falling, and perhaps a cozy fireplace in the background. The image should capture the essence of popular Christmas songs, with musical notes and lyrics subtly included in the design, representing a playlist of classic Christmas tunes.

summer

Immediate’s iconic brands reach 21m people every month – that’s more than a third of the UK’s adults – through its world-class magazines, innovative digital products and exciting live eventsImmediate’s iconic brands reach 21m people every month – that’s more than a third of the UK’s adults – through its world-class magazines, innovative digital products and exciting live eventsImmediate’s iconic brands reach 21m people every month – that’s more than a third of the UK’s adults – through its world-class magazines, innovative digital products and exciting live events

More